Exhaust problem 99 Corolla is cracked

The front engine pipe gasket of my 99 Corolla is cracked. The Toyota dealer had given an estimate of $290 a while ago without giving a breakup of parts & labor. Direct Tire people gave an estimate of $135. I would prefer to take it to the dealer, but it's almost double. Is it safe to take it to Direct Tire (or any other service station)? If so, what should I be wary of? Thanks. The dealer may have wanted to replace more but you don't have that itemization. Without seeing what the exact problem is any decent tech should be able to do a responsible job so I would go for the best value for you,

Thanks; I plan to go with Direct Tire.
I believe your exhaust that is vulnerable is the rear portion which will come in one peice pre-made and is available aftermarket which is fine. I would go for the price. What I don't like is when muffler shops make their own stuff and weld it all up such that individual parts would be very troublesome to replace later or impossible with the mig welders and other equipment I couldn't profit from owning so I just buy exact pre-made parts for whatever vehicle as needed.

It's makes sense for you to go for the bargain,